The Persistence of Creationism

Your Curmudgeon is not and never will be a sociologist. Nevertheless, it’s obvious even to us that humans have evolved to be social animals, undoubtedly because of the survival benefit of living in cooperative groups, rather than being solitary misanthropic individuals.

In that context, we can perceive that there are benefits to religion. If a group’s religion is voluntary, it can be both beneficial (by promoting the group’s cohesion) and also enjoyable, because people like getting together with others who share the same cultural values. But religion isn’t the only institution that can fill such needs — at least in our culture. There are many voluntary associations that can serve the same functions — whether professional, political, charitable, or purely social. There are even seemingly trivial ones like participating in some kind of ephemeral internet hashtag community. We humans have developed a number of ways to satisfy our social needs.

But religion, like politics, can morph into malignant institutions. This happens when they cease to be voluntary — compulsion in such matters being obviously undesirable (at least for those being compelled). Also, they can develop dogmas and practices that promote ignorance, isolation, fear, and aggression. They then cease to be beneficial. Such institutions often tend to either self-destruct or to be defeated by less pernicious societies. History is littered with examples.

However, there are some wayward institutions that not only persist, but which seem to thrive. This is not only because they benefit their leadership, who are motivated to maintain the institutions, but also because they actually do provide a sense of community for unfortunate individuals who have been raised in ignorance and isolation. For them, regardless of the deleterious effects of the institution, it’s a voluntary association, providing a desirable sense of belonging they can’t find elsewhere because — even if they are functional — they are uncomfortable in the larger society. We put creationists in this category.

Aside from their behavior within their groups, and despite their desires, creationists haven’t become aggressive totalitarians — at least not since the days of the Inquisition. Well, there’s the Middle East, but that’s another story. Here in the West, things seem to be under control. They haven’t tried to ban the teaching of evolution since the Scopes Trial, and their slightly more subtle “teach both sides” approach hasn’t been deployed since Edwards v. Aguillard. Their latest assault on science is the intelligent design movement, but that’s been effectively dead since Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District. Nevertheless, they keep trying.

In all likelihood, for the rest of your life you’ll be hearing their slogans like “critical analysis,” “teach both sides,” “teach evolution’s strengths and weaknesses,” “academic freedom,” and “viewpoint discrimination.” Creationists will be demanding that public schools should “Let the children decide!” and “Stop the censorship.” They’ll be asking: “What are you afraid of?” and “Why do you persecute those with whom you disagree?” And they’ll continue promoting their anti-evolution Academic Freedom bills.

Despite all the noise they make, creationism has had no positive impact on science, industry, agriculture, medicine, or any other rational endeavor — nor are any accomplishments likely in the future. Creationism, like astrology, flat-Earthism, geocentricism, and dozens of other crackpot beliefs, is the pathway to intellectual oblivion. But it’s not going away.

As the moth is drawn to the flame, so too does the simpleton seek the charlatan. Therefore, creationism will always be with us.

Copyright © 2016. The Sensuous Curmudgeon. All rights reserved.

add to del.icio.usAdd to Blinkslistadd to furlDigg itadd to ma.gnoliaStumble It!add to simpyseed the vineTailRankpost to facebook

. AddThis Social Bookmark Button . Permalink for this article

8 responses to “The Persistence of Creationism

  1. Creationists will be demanding that pubic schools should

    Hm, surprised this got through the filters . . .

  2. realthog says: “Hm, surprised this got through the filters . . .”

    Me too. Well, it’s fixed now. Very embarrassing.

  3. The religious already write bills against gays and abortions. Totalitarian.

  4. Charles Deetz ;)

    The harder they hold on, the shriller they get, the more likely the next generation will see them as antiquated … and steer clear of them. Hambo complains about exactly this, but his solution is that they just need to learn his bible facts. It’ll be an interesting lesson to bible thumpers if Ted Cruz wins the delegate battle. They’ll think they’ve got the guy who knows what is right. Everyone else is going to have fun roasting him (and them).

  5. Aside from their behavior within their groups, and despite their desires, creationists haven’t become aggressive totalitarians — at least not since the days of the Inquisition.

    But quite a few would if they could, and will if they can.

  6. But religion, like politics, can morph into malignant institutions.

    It’s important to make a distinction between tolerant religions and those of a fundamentalist bent. The fundies are all about mind control and primarily use their strict interpretation of the bible and the teachings of the prophets as the cornerstone for their control the flock and their rejection of other faiths. The word of god is their mantra and dissent is not tolerated. Their twisted offspring is called creationism and is the natural fundamentalist reflex to the challenges of science and technology. As long as there are people willing to be told what to do to secure their place in heaven, there will be both fundamentalists and creationists.

    Can they have an negative impact, nevermind positive, on mainstream culture? Well if the malignancy that currently afflicts Islam continues to spread, I’m talking about the Sharia and its 300 million adherents, then yes a potential new dark ages could befall western civilization. The battle between enlightenment and the forces of ignorance will be forever until human nature changes. The destruction of ancient temples by ISIS is a harbinger of the countless Hypatia’s that will die at the hands of ignorance in the years to come.

  7. “creationism will always be with us”
    Always is an awfully long time.

  8. Stupidity will always be with us.

    But one day, we will suddenly realize that there isn’t any Intelligent Design to talk about any more, and Young Earth Creationism will be as influential as The Flat Earth. We will wonder what happened. There will be some people who will deny that there was any such thing as YEC in the 20th century, that will be the only controversy.

    Anyway, that is what I think will happen, all of a sudden.